How Do Driving Instructor Insurance Claims Affect Future Premiums?

Find out how driving instructor insurance claims can affect future premiums, including what influences costs and how to manage your insurance after a claim.

Rhys Taylor
Rhys TaylorAugust 18, 2026 · 5 min read
A driving examiner with clipboard watches a young woman inspect a car tire near orange traffic cones during a driving test.

Insurers assess risk differently and may consider factors such as the type of claim, who was responsible, your claims history and the circumstances of the incident when calculating your future premium.

If you're a driving instructor, understanding how claims can affect your insurance can help you make informed decisions about your cover.

Will making a claim increase my driving instructor insurance premium?

It can, but it isn't possible to say exactly how much your premium will increase.

Insurers use their own underwriting criteria when calculating premiums, so the effect of a claim can vary between insurers and individual policyholders. A claim may indicate to an insurer that the risk of future claims is higher, which can result in a higher premium at renewal.

Other factors will also continue to affect your premium, such as your vehicle, postcode, driving history and annual mileage.

Does a claim affect my no-claims bonus?

A claim can affect your no-claims bonus (NCD), but the outcome depends on the circumstances of the claim and the terms of your policy.

For example, the Financial Ombudsman Service explains that a fault claim will typically reduce an unprotected no-claims bonus, although the exact reduction depends on the insurer's policy.

If an insurer recovers its costs from the responsible third party, a claim that initially affected your no-claims bonus may be treated differently once liability has been established.

Your policy documents should explain how your no-claims bonus works and what happens following a claim.

What is a fault claim?

A fault claim doesn't necessarily mean that you caused the accident.

A claim can be recorded as a fault claim when the accident was your fault, but it can also apply where your insurer cannot recover the costs of the claim from another party.

For example, if another driver damages your vehicle but cannot be identified, your insurer may be unable to recover the cost of the claim.

This is why it's important to understand how your insurer has classified a claim rather than assuming that "fault" always means you caused the accident.

What happens if the accident wasn't my fault?

If another driver was responsible and your insurer successfully recovers its costs from their insurer, the claim may not have the same impact on your no-claims bonus.

However, the situation can be more complicated while liability is still being established. If your insurer has paid for damage to your vehicle and hasn't yet recovered those costs, your no-claims bonus may temporarily be affected.

The eventual outcome of the claim can therefore matter.

Can a non-fault claim still increase my premium?

Yes, it is possible.

A non-fault accident can still provide an insurer with information about your claims history and may affect how it assesses the risk of insuring you in the future.

The Financial Ombudsman Service notes that insurers may consider an incident when setting premiums, even where the policyholder's no-claims bonus is not reduced.

This means that having a protected no-claims bonus does not necessarily guarantee that your premium will remain unchanged after an accident.

Does driving instructor insurance cover personal use?

Some driving instructor insurance policies can include personal use alongside professional driving tuition.

This can allow you to use your vehicle outside of lessons, such as for shopping, social journeys or other permitted personal activities.

The amount and type of personal use available will vary between policies, so check the permitted use stated in your policy documents.

Does protecting my no-claims bonus prevent my premium from increasing?

No. Protecting your no-claims bonus and protecting the price of your insurance are two different things.

No-claims protection can allow you to retain some or all of your existing no-claims discount after an eligible claim, depending on the policy.

However, the insurer can still reassess the underlying risk and increase the premium at renewal. The Financial Ombudsman Service specifically notes that protected no-claims bonuses do not necessarily prevent premiums from increasing following a claim.

For example, you could retain your no-claims discount but still pay more because the insurer has changed the underlying premium.

How long does a claim affect your insurance?

There isn't one fixed period that applies to every insurer or every claim.

Insurers have their own criteria for assessing previous claims and deciding how they affect future premiums. The type of claim, when it occurred and your wider claims history can all be relevant.

When obtaining a new quote, you should provide accurate information about previous claims and incidents for the period the insurer asks about.

Do multiple claims affect insurance premiums more?

Having multiple claims can affect how an insurer assesses your risk, although there isn't a universal formula for how much your premium will increase.

Insurers can consider the number and nature of previous claims when calculating a premium. The impact will depend on the insurer's underwriting criteria and your individual circumstances.

For a driving instructor, this can be particularly relevant because your vehicle may be used for professional tuition for many hours each week.

Should I avoid making a claim to protect my premium?

Not necessarily.

If you've suffered an insured loss, whether to make a claim is a decision that should be considered in the context of your policy and circumstances. You shouldn't assume that avoiding a claim will always be financially better.

It's also important to remember that your policy may require you to notify your insurer about an accident or incident, even if you don't intend to make a claim.

The Financial Ombudsman Service notes that insurers may require incidents to be reported, and an incident can remain on an insurer's records even when no claim is ultimately made.

Always check your policy conditions before deciding not to report an incident.

Can reporting an accident without making a claim affect my premium?

It can.

Reporting an incident doesn't necessarily mean that your no-claims bonus will be reduced if no claim is made. However, insurers may still take the incident into account when assessing the risk and setting a future premium.

This is why you should follow the reporting requirements in your policy rather than deciding whether to report an incident based solely on its potential effect on your premium.

What can I do to keep my driving instructor insurance premiums down?

You cannot control every factor an insurer uses to calculate your premium, but there are some steps you can take to help manage the cost of your insurance.

These include:

  • Drive safely and maintain a good driving record.

  • Provide accurate information when getting a quote.

  • Keep your insurer informed of relevant changes to your circumstances.

  • Consider your vehicle carefully when choosing or replacing your tuition car.

  • Check whether you have an eligible no-claims bonus.

  • Compare suitable insurance options when your policy is due for renewal.

  • Make sure you understand the cover and excess provided by your policy.

The cheapest policy isn't necessarily the most appropriate, particularly if it doesn't provide the cover you need as a driving instructor.

Read More:

How Much Does Driving Instructor Insurance Cost?

Instructor insurance costs

What happens to my insurance after a claim?

Following a claim, your insurer will assess the incident according to the terms of your policy. Depending on the circumstances, your claim may affect your no-claims bonus, future premiums or both.

At renewal, the insurer will reassess the risk and provide a new premium based on its current pricing and underwriting criteria. There is no guaranteed percentage increase following a claim because insurers use different pricing models.

If you're unhappy with the way a claim has been handled or believe your insurer has incorrectly recorded a claim, you can raise a complaint with the insurer and, where appropriate, the Financial Ombudsman Service.

Get driving instructor insurance with BG Insurance

Claims are one of several factors that can influence the cost of your driving instructor insurance. Your individual circumstances, vehicle and insurance requirements will all be considered when obtaining a quote.

BG Insurance specialises in insurance for driving instructors, including ADIs, PDIs and driving schools.

If you're looking for driving instructor insurance, BG Insurance can help you explore your options and find cover based on your circumstances.


Rhys Taylor
Rhys Taylor
Marketing Director, BG Insurance

Rhys Taylor is Marketing Director at BG Insurance, a specialist UK insurance broker for driving instructors, trainee instructors and driving schools. He oversees BG Insurance's guides, which help instructors understand their cover, manage risk and protect their business on the road.

Frequently AskedQuestions

It can, but it isn't possible to say exactly how much your premium will increase. Insurers use their own underwriting criteria when calculating premiums, so the effect of a claim can vary between insurers and individual policyholders.

Save on your Driving Instructor insurance

Join over 9,000 driving professionals who trust BG Insurance to protect their livelihood.

Blue Volkswagen driving school car with BG Insurance branding and L plates on roof, bonnet and doors.

Recent Articles

Close-up of a dashboard camera mounted on a car windshield, recording the road ahead.

How To Make A Claim

Making an insurance claim can be stressful. However, knowing the process and following best practices can help. This will improve your chances of a smooth outcome.

Read More
A driving instructor gestures at a knocked-over traffic cone while a stressed female student sits in a black car during a driving test.

How Claims History Affects Driving Instructor Insurance Premiums

As a driving instructor, your car is more than transport. It is the foundation of your business. But when it comes to driving instructor insurance, one of the biggest factors influencing your premium is your claims history. Understanding how insurers assess past claims, accidents, and no-claims bonuses can help you manage costs and keep your driving school insurance competitive.

Read More
Woman using smartphone beside yellow SUV being loaded onto a tow truck on a roadside.

The Hidden Costs of Dual Control Car Accidents And How Insurance Protects You

Driving instructors know that accidents can happen at any time. Even with dual controls, a learner can make a mistake that leads to damage or injury. Many instructors think only about the repair bill for their car, but the truth is that accidents can create hidden costs. This is where driving school insurance and driving instructor insurance make a real difference.

Read More